A matter of Conscience: Why we need to act on long term care right now, and why transparency with Covid data is more critical than ever

It came as a surprise to no one, that the recent report from Seniors Advocate, Isobel Mackenzie revealed that many if not most residents in long term care, worried less about Covid than going without seeing their loved ones. They are wasting away from lonelieness and being drugged at unprecedented rates. The full report can and should be read here. https://www.seniorsadvocatebc.ca/osa-reports/staying-apart-to-stay-safe-survey/

It has been horrendous to see the stories shared online from family members of those in long term care.

Residents who stopped eating, residents who families report they died of loneliness and isolation, refusing to eat, rather than covid. I remarked in my last post, that it was ironic that this was the year we released inmates early, while locking up seniors, both in the name of safety. And it’s not working. Not for residents and not for families.

The stark truth really is that keeping families and residents separated to keep covid out of long term care homes, is cruel and hasn’t worked. Outbreaks continue to occur, staff and residents continue to get sick and some sadly, continue to die. So its time we acknowledge this and act immediately to fix this. 9 months is a ridiculous amount of time and care homes are not complying with visitation consistently. I just spoke with an old friend who shared her story of being separated from her mum all this time. It brought me to tears.

This does not need to wait until a new minister is sworn in. This can be implemented by ministry staff immediately. And it is long past time for the public health officer, Dr. Bonnie Henry, to mandate frequent testing of staff, to ensure asymptomatic, or pre-symptomatic staff do not continue to inadvertently bring in the virus. This is something many have been calling for, for months to no avail. Concerned citizens have been calling for this for months online, and families continue to, particularly loudly now that we are in a second wave.

Most recently,care workers and their union joined the call for mandated and frequent testing, because it is a terrible burden on the staff to bear, and unconscionable when the movie industry in BC mandates more frequent testing of everyone on set, than we do of those in care of our most vulnerable members of society.

So why aren’t we doing this?

Why was it deemed exceptionally critical for NHL players to have routine, frequent testing so fans can watch hockey…and yet care home staff are not?

This is, after all, the segment of the population most at risk from serious complication and death. The ones we are told we need to protect the most. Mandatory frequent testing *will* reduce outbreaks and make it easier and safer to reunite families.

Dr. Bonnie Henry was asked about this on August 24th of this year. The video is below. She speaks to false positives and false negatives, and that in her mind, it is not the best use of resources, something repeated even in news stories linked to above.

I’m not a scientist, or a doctor and won’t pretend to be, so I’m not even going to bother speaking to false positives or false negatives. But I will speak to the fact that in every industry – NHL, NFL, and movie – mandated and frequent testing has and does catch people who are positive before or without symptoms, and it keeps those people isolated until tested negative. If it saves lives of staff and residents of long term care, how can anyone say it isnt a good use of resources?

Blanket testing is what ultimately was used – only when the outbreak continued into a third week – in the first Holy Cross outbreak, as told by Vancouver Coastal Healths Patricia Daly, in this video presentation.

When we have community spread as significant as there is in Metro Vancouver, with as many as 20% of cases not having an identified source of transmission, it is my view that we have an obligation to both these long term care residents, and to the staff caring for them, that is not being met.

These staff have lives, children, spouses and elders of their own. When we fail to use the tools we have at hand to ensure asymptomatic/pre-symptomatic staff are caught, we are being negligent because the vast majority of deaths have incurred in or related to long term care. And even if up to 30% of tests give false positives or negatives, that means 70% are accurate. Tell me how this isn’t the best use of resources if minimizing deaths is a key goal of all we are doing? We know it isn’t family bringing it in. This was confirmed.

At the very least, it seems we have failed to learn to apply the precautionary principle on so many aspects a lesson many failed to learn from SARS. https://www.google.ca/amp/s/lailayuile.com/2020/03/31/lessons-not-learned-from-the-sars-inquiry-the-precautionary-principle-be-expressly-adopted-as-a-guiding-principle/amp/

And then yesterday… this:

At a time when public trust is lagging in many areas, giving less info isn’t the right thing to do. Particularly when it is is followed on the heels by this story: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-data-sharing-health-workers-phac-holes-1.5788386

B.C. has stopped sharing data on the occupational status of people who test positive for COVID-19, deeming that data too sensitive to share, according to the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC).

That data includes how many positive COVID-19 cases involve doctors, nurses or health-care workers.

Data analysts say that’s a problem because tracking such positive cases is a crucial marker that can reveal if the health-care system is coming under too much stress β€” but there’s not much the federal agency can do about it except “ask nice” because the data is owned by the province.

[PHAC] can confirm that we have not received any information on occupational status of COVID-19 cases from the province of British Columbia since June 2020,” reads an email from a Statistics Canada analyst.

Provincial Health Officer Dr. Bonnie Henry denied this was the case when CBC asked her about the issue on Oct. 15

We have not stopped sharing that. … We do provide that information and certainly provide it on request,” she said. “

Henry said the B.C. Centre for Disease Control gathers occupational information and there have been some recent changes to how cases are defined to collect more detail, so reporting “changed slightly … but we’ve certainly reported on health worker data.”

??? ??? Either this is a significant miscommunication, or someone isn’t telling the truth, but either way this data is critical to ensuring evolving policy and procedures with respect to health care workers. This shouldn’t be an issue, yet data and information hoarding has been a hallmark of how Covid is handled in BC. Since the beginnng, there has been a data void with respect to case details. Location was taboo. Stigma was brought up as the reason and not one city knows how many cases they may have at any given time. Is it any wonder people become complacent and fatigued?

In September, a coalition of BC First Nations filed an application with the information and privacy commissioner to have the info shared, so they can protect their own communities better. The fact they had been denied this info before, is bizarre. https://vancouverisland.ctvnews.ca/b-c-first-nations-coalition-calls-for-covid-19-case-location-information-1.5105592

Since then, we still remain largely in a data void and what data is given isnt specific. Parents have created their own website tracking school exposures in metro van, often far ahead of public health. We are short of contract tracers and the publics interest in paying attention is waning in many areas.

Now more than ever, we need transparency to keep people on board. Justin McElroy got to the heart of this in some recent tweets following a presser earlier this week.

Excellent and thoughtful points.

I also suggest something that would help to keep people vigilant,would be to include a new statement on the number of ” recovered ” people being followed for long haul symptoms and complications, right after the total number of recovered patients. This is being documented in BC, Dr. Henry confirmed this in an earlier presser, and the numbers are not small. This keeps the reality that many covid patients of all ages are sometimes left with long term symptoms…something I just recently saw the BC Government twitter account mention in a reply:

I think many forget about this. And it isn’t covered enough locally in the news, despite it being a serious and ongoing aspect of Covid. Too many discount Covid on the small death toll in BC alone, forgetting.many are left unable to work for months if not indefinitely.

When you withhold info, people grow suspicious.

When you provide all the info, trust is earned.

For now, I go, with the hope that our leaders act fast to ensure our elders see their loved ones and don’t continue to sit drugged and/or alone. Think out of the box. Rapid tests for visitors, outside tents with heaters, I fail to see why these things can’t be done. Share the data, build trust by acknowledging failures and mistakes, and move forward. Its going to be a long winter and we need to get through it as unscathed as possible, and that requires a lot of trust.

On a personal note, posts will continue to be sporadic, but I am toying with ideas of how to keep people engaged and checking in through this winter, when darkness and isolation will close in for many. Is there something you would like to see? Let me know.

12 Comments on “A matter of Conscience: Why we need to act on long term care right now, and why transparency with Covid data is more critical than ever

    • Thank you Ron, for being such a strong advocate on this. πŸ™ I linked to your post in my pre elections blog too. Its an important piece and it still astounds me they waited 3 weeks to do blanket testing.

      What happened to the precautionary principle?

      What happened to caring about how staff and family feel?

      What happened to doing the right thing?

      They refuse to mandate masks, yet mandated what happens in peoples private homes and yards across BC, rather than deal with the issue in Frasef Health head on in August.
      Banquet hall owners warned them this would happen, people having massive gatherings at home, because the banquet halls were closed. When it got out of control during the election, it was too late. They waited too long to deal with it.

      Keep at it Ron, you, Salim Jiwa and others are on the right side of history. Don’t forget that. When the inquiry happens,this will be remembered. These elders deserve better, no matter their age.

  1. And the all knowing protector and gaurdian of Henry and Dix’s realm of recklessness and lies, Keith Baldrey and the likes of those government smitten sheep, continue to throw their sparkly fairy dusted rubber lighting bolts at the rest of us regular concerned people from all walks of life that are only exercising their right at being objective and critical of the weakness and negligence that is helping to fuel this crisis and spread, because of what many see as dangerous incompetence with much arrogance and stubborness thrown in.
    The school protection and safety issues are really disturbing. A reflection of the political playing maniacs in charge. Could the schools be Dix, Flemings, and Henry’s pet project that they want protected at any cost. Sick, sick sick. But why would they not have stronger implemented orders and measures in place by having smaller classes and mask policy by order now that we know the virus spread way more easily. On the federal level, I see Tam and Liars incorporated are being questioned and caught in their lies and spin on the quiet change about the transmissabiliy. Gee wasn’t this concern there for quite a long time now from the science and information and concern by professionals of all sorts. And Ah huh Bonnie Henry and sheepish Dix still want everyone to buy in and be responsible. Holy Shit i think were being that especially when it comes to the stupid and irresponsible.
    Don’t forget though. Any concerned, questioning and critical parents, teachers, staff and all good regular mainstream folks are called unscrupulous and armchair experts etc. etc. by some arrogant high horse riding jerks, in some slimy corners the media and press gallery world.

    And love seeing Ron Hughes here. It’s an honour. Keep up the hitting back at madness.

    • Ron Hughes is amazing. He and Salim Jiwa have done the work and asked the questions the media should be, but don’t.

      Super frustrating right now I now, but I want to ask you to please keep from name calling etc. There is enough to bring attention to without it all and sometimes it takes away from the sentiment of your comments, which are good and have great observations like this one πŸ™‚

  2. Sorry I’m rushing to much to not correct my sentences in the comment. I wanted to say Holy shit I think we’re beyond that especially when it comes to the stupid and irresponsible.

  3. I see todays announcements and orders by Bonnie Henry don’t include school class sizes or more stringent masking or any talk of the possible interconnecting silent spread in school, from homes and and then back to homes and to every ones homes. It seems The tentacles of reach are all there too. I don’t mind saying. Playing politics with peoples lives to keep schools opens. Why on gods earth would these negligent political playing Health officials and Cherry picking Governing incompetents and F… Ups not shut down schools for two weeks also at least. To think these people that are payed by us to represent us on safety is just sick. I’ve lost all respect for Henry, Dix and there dirty masters. there all the same. NDP scum politicians or Liberal scum politicians.

    • I agree entirely.

      It was absolutely ridiculous to wait until the day after the election, to first do anything.This issue of big gatherings at peoples homes has been known since they shut down banquet halls. She has said since early on it takes 2 weeks minimum to see the effect of gatherings or of restrictions,so why did they wait until this weekend? Because Diwali is coming.

      Now we have a restriction on outdoor gatherings to the point of ” Don’t let a walk turn into a social event” FFS, they have been telling folks since day 1, meeting friends distanced outside is the safest thing, we literally just went through an entire election campaign where there is photo evidence of politicians meeting with many people outside, masked and in some cases unmasked, schools are entirely open in metro van, no one has actually had a bubble for 2 full months if you have more than one kid in different schools… and now, these measures that still, when viewed from what is allowed at workplaces and schools and malls and superstore and malls, make little sense to many.

      Here on Van Isle, we are very lucky so far. We are doing all the things we normally do, and its because we really just found new, safe ways to continue on. Kids are in school in full classes and enjoying it. But in dense populations, you do not have the luxury of space. School should never have gone back in the density it did, and the ministry abdicated its responsibilities to students, teachers and parents in Metro Van.

      FYI. They were saying the same thing in Quebec, officials are still saying here in BC about school not driving spread. |And this is where they are now.

      https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/quebec-schools-second-wave-1.5791616

  4. This is unconscionable.

    https://mobile.twitter.com/realreporter/status/1326310146411098112

    I would beg you all to call your mla’s and ask for mandatory frequent testing of staff in every long term facing ASAP.. But the mlas have not been sworn in and I’m hearing offices are not answering calls.

    Many of these people have said they would prefer death over being isolated but that DOES NOT MEAN WE SHOULD LET THEM DIE.

    Mandatory frequent testing works. It works in the film industry and it works in other places where they do frequent testing of staff.

    Why are we not doing it here?

    Why? These are the people we are trying to protect are we not?

    Why aren’t we doing what we know will prevent outbreaks from starting altogether?

  5. I’m so frustrated to listen to DBH go on and on about protecting our elders while she refuses to order or mandate all long term care homes to do proactive, frequent testing of all staff.

    They know this works. Its why the movie industry does it.

    This is fucked up when making TV shows is more important that keeping elders safe in homes they were admitted to for proper care.
    Many have been literally locked up for 9 months with no family visits. Many have declined in that time and as we know, many would rather risk covid than not see their loved ones.

    But so long as there are outbreaks, those visits * will not happen *. Some will die without touching their loved ones in 9 months or longer as time goes on.

    There is a solution and Dr. Henry has said she doesn’t think its a good use of resources.

    I vehemently disagree. This is a public post should you wish to share.

    We are failing our elders in ways I could never have imagined.

    We are hamstrung without a sworn in government to demand change from.

    And reporters who don’t seem willing to challenge or question when it so desperately needs to be done.

    If you care about this, make a call, I have no idea which mlas offices are open but please call..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.